The Hardest Question was an experiment in preaching the Revised Common Lectionary. All posting is finished, but the content will continue to live here in archive form. You can discover new content by former THQ curator Russell Rathbun at Question the Text.


Stephen the Martyr

Do we know a martyr when we see one?

by Tripp Hudgins

New Testament Reading:  Acts 7:55-60   

For Sunday, May 22, 2011:  Year A - Easter 5

Mr. Spock, in the second of the Star Trek films sacrifices himself at the end of the movie saying, “The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few…or the one.” Yes, he sacrifices himself for the sake of his crew mates and friends. Spock is a hero. But is Spock a martyr? It is unclear…especially since he dumped his consciousness into Dr. McCoy’s head.

A hero is one who sacrifices themselves for a so-called greater good. Their own actions, however, are sometimes violent and lead to their own violent end. Even if something “good” comes from it, heroes are often perpetrators of violence. See: every action movie ever made.

Stephen’s Story

The story of Stephen is, as tradition reminds us, the story of the first martyr. Stephen is the first of the followers of Jesus to die because of his faithful witness. There is a labor shortage and the Twelve need some help. Stephen is one of seven appointed as a someone of good standing, one filled with the Holy Spirit, and wisdom (Acts 6:3). According to the story, Stephen gets right to work and his preaching lands him in a religious court facing trumped up charges. During his trial he lays out his defense and it so scandalizes those present that they take him to the edge of town and stone him. He kneels and offers his spirit up to Jesus his last breath asking forgiveness for his killers. Saul, who would become Paul, is there to witness it all.

Death Seekers?

Throughout the history of the Church we have held up men and women who have lived out the call to follow Christ in dramatic and life altering fashion. Many of these men and women have died in the process. These we have called “martyrs.” They have been enshrined in basilicas, cathedrals, and oratories for centuries. Believers were known to go out seeking their deaths hoping for a one-way ticket to heaven. We have a long and strange history of seeking death in the name of Jesus.

The Stand

Dietrich Bonhoeffer is famous for the statement “Christ bids us come and die.” It’s not a particularly uplifting-Joel-Osteen understanding of the Gospel. Up With People likely would not adopt this as their mission statement. Still, it stares us in the face. Bonhoeffer is speaking of dying to self as well as the knowledge that where God calls the believer to stand might be a dangerous place. His own life would reflect this reality. Yet, he dies not for his faith but because of his participation in a plot to assassinate Adolph Hitler. Many still disagree on whether or not he was a martyr. Perhaps he was a hero, but a martyr?

The Hardest Question

Is Stephen a hero or martyr? He is killed because of what he professed. He is not a violent man and poses no real obvious threat to the powers that be. He simply states something that they do not want to hear: their own culpability in systems of violence. Yet he cajoles them. Is he looking for trouble? He almost appears to be grandstanding. Is Stephen really a martyr? Do we know a martyr when we see one?

Tripp Hudgins is baptimonastic, mandolin-playing Jesus enthusiast, a preaching pastor, baptist cantor, liturgist, ecumenist, writer of articles, tangentist, and husband. He is the pastor of The Community Church of Wilmette in Wilmette, IL, a suburb of Chicago. His blog can be found at and he tweets as @anglobaptist.


  1. Denise Richardson says:

    Looking for the year Stephen was martyred for his belief. But…, didn’t find it in this article. I have gotten dates, 2 years after Christ died (by the Catholics); 3 1/2 years, by the Seventh Day Adventist; and a date of 57 A.D. by a Sunday School teacher. There has to be a way of dating Stephen’s death by the true study of the Bible (a translations, NOT an interpretation Bible. I’ll keep looking for the answer. If, Stephen died exactly 3 1/2 years after Christ died, then Cathosism and 95 percent of all Protestants believers have been taught a bunch of shit by false prophets, but if Stephen died exactly 3 1/2 years after Christ’s death, then…, the seventh week should remain with the other 69 weeks (time of the Jews) and the last week was a detailed explanation of what would all take place in that last week. Meaning, Jesus was baptised at the beginning of the week, in the middle of the week, the oblation would stop (Christ died on the cross, thus, blood ordances were stopped), and if 3 1/2 years later Stephen was martyred for his faith, which would end the last week and begin the time of the Gentiles…, the whole doctrine of Catholics and most Protestants would be blown out of the water (regarding the end time events). Hope you are an investigator of the truth, instead of a dumf-ass believer in listening to whatever doctrine blows your way. Study the word for truth.

How do you read?